So I was talking with some scuba instructors lately and it was interesting to hear what they think you should teach to students, that is brand new Open Water students. Some feel you should push them and do things like equipment exchanges to built their confidence. Some feel you should just do the minimal amount and just meet the standards. I am of the believe some were in between. What I mean is an open water student is still figuring out if they want to do this sport. This would be the same thing as give a snow skier lessons for a few days then send them down the double black diamond slope to see how they handle them self. If this were a Dive Master candidate knows they want to go and start to teach and share their love for the sport, they will need to see how they handle stress and I do see pushing them, but more the reason of to see how they handle a difficult situation. So here is my approach: I think an Open Water diver should get comfortable in the water with diving. I like to get threw the skills and have about half an hour of just swimming, then I play games like any student can ask any staff to do a skill and the same in the other way. A staff can ask any student to do any skill that they have learned. This way you can have fun and learn at the same time.
So what are your thoughts?